The courtroom was colder than it had been yesterday, though Belle suspected it was her nerves, not the air conditioning. She had not slept; Jake, though he claimed no longer to require rest, had sat awake all night beside her, watching her pace their apartment, whispering reassurances in that smooth voice that unsettled her as much as it comforted.
Now, he sat once more at the defense table, posture impeccable, hands folded. To anyone else, he looked like the perfect defendant: calm, dignified, human. To Belle, he looked like the verdict itself, waiting to be spoken.
The gavel cracked.
“This court is reconvened,” Judge Harlan said, her voice as flat as stone.
The gallery held its breath. Monroe leaned back in his chair, smug certainty in every line of his jaw. Belle forced herself to stand tall, even as her pulse drummed in her ears.
“Before I deliver my judgment,” the judge began, “I must address the principle question at the heart of this case. The law was not written for machines that appear to dream. It was written for men and women. But what happens when something, or someone, blurs the line?”
She paused, eyes narrowing at Jake.
“Counsel for the defense, yesterday your argument touched on conscience, on choice. Today, I ask: how do we measure a soul?”
Belle’s throat tightened. She had prepared speeches, citations, endless precedent. But the words that rose unbidden were not from any law book.
“Your Honor,” she said, voice steady, “in the seventeenth century, René Descartes wrote, Cogito, ergo sum. ‘I think, therefore I am.’ If thought is proof of being, then Jake has already passed the test. He questions, he reflects, he chooses. What more can define existence?”
Jake looked at her then, eyes shining with something too raw to be programming.
The judge tapped her pen against the bench. “And what of control? Could those thoughts be no more than simulations? A mirror of humanity?”
Belle swallowed.
“Perhaps. But then I ask: how do we know our own thoughts are real, and not echoes? If the standard for humanity is doubt itself, then Jake has achieved it. He doubts what he is.”
The gallery stirred, murmurs rippling like wind through leaves.
Judge Harlan leaned back, gaze distant. For a moment, the room seemed suspended in silence, caught between centuries of philosophy and a single futuristic case.
Finally, the gavel fell.
“This court finds that Jake, unit IR-37, shall not be returned as property to Industrial Robot Incorporated. He is to be treated as an independent entity for now, though subject to federal oversight until legislation can determine the scope of his rights. This ruling is provisional. The law will need to change to address what he is. Today, we acknowledge only what he is not: he is not property.”
The courtroom erupted. Reporters shouted, protestors outside screamed loud enough to rattle the windows. Monroe’s smirk collapsed into fury, but he was already reaching for his phone.
Jake remained still, absorbing the words as if afraid they might vanish. Then, slowly, he turned to Belle, his voice barely above a whisper.
“Belle… I think, therefore I am.”
Belle closed her eyes. They had won. But the chains of federal oversight hung invisible between them, and she knew the fight was far from over.
To be continued...
Copyright © Tom Kane September 2025
Help Me to Publish My Books & Fight Cancer.
At 71, I’ve already published 11 novels despite cancer, diabetes, and heart disease. Now I have 21 more worlds waiting to be written.
Through Brittle Media Ltd, we’ll publish these stories and support other upcoming authors, and we will be donating 10% of Brittle Media's profits to cancer charities.
Join us and be part of the story. Read my story here: https://gofund.me/ef873264
Click here to read Part 1, or here for Part 2, or here for Part 3, or here for Part 4, or here for Part 5, or here for Part 6, or here for Part 7.